u/Puzzleheaded_Fee_646 in r/Perfumes
commented on a 67-upvote post
Fruity Almond, their dupe for Good Girl
14
Reply Share The best Carolina Herrera Good Girl dupe, verified by 3 sources
We cross-checked 5 community citations (Reddit comments, posts, clonespreadsheet ratings) and one pair emerged consistently: Dossier Fruity Almond.
Why we verified this dupe
Cross-source agreement across brand product pages, Reddit comments, Reddit posts.
Reddit comments (3 citations)
u/SamSweet in r/Perfumes
commented on a 255-upvote post
their Fruity Almond is *good enough*... Don't get me wrong it's a great dupe
2
Reply Share 
u/IzackNoel in r/Perfumes
commented on a 10-upvote post
It's the dupe to Good Girl... they smell IDENTICAL to each other
2
Reply Share Reddit posts (2 citations)
r/Perfumes
Posted by u/Shelbythecat1
Finally put up a display for my collection!
Dossier Fruity Almond (CH Good Girl dupe)
r/Perfumes
Posted by u/Willowblosom
Labeled my dossier dupes with the original inspired by scents!
Fruity Almond- Carolina Herrara Good Girl
More verified dupes you might want
Picked by shared brand or accord family, every one cross-verified by the community.
-
OriginalYves Saint LaurentBlack Opium→ Dossier Ambery Vanilla80% verified by 3 sources -
OriginalBillie EilishEilish→ Lattafa Nebras80% verified by 2 sources -
OriginalBy KilianLove Don't Be Shy→ Dossier Floral Marshmallow100% verified by 3 sources -
OriginalBy KilianAngels' Share→ Lattafa Khamrah70% verified by 2 sources -
OriginalParfums de MarlyAlthaïr→ Fragrance World Liquid Brun85% verified by 3 sources -
OriginalTom FordTobacco Vanille→ Al Haramain Amber Oud Tobacco Edition92% verified by 3 sources